Постановление ЕСПЧ от 09.02.2016 <Дело Баранов и другие (Baranov and Others) против России> (жалобы N 24130/04, 24916/04, 38108/04, 43535/04, 1711/05, 13825/06, 14070/06, 14101/06, 17664/06, 25722/06, 25798/06, 45413/06, 19942/07, 39661/07, 47465/07, 8295/08, 52271/08 и 55432/08) [англ.] Часть 2

1   2

Appendix

No. Application no. and date of introduction Applicant name

Date of birth

Place of residence

Nationality

Represented by

Final domestic judgment

a) date of delivery

b) date of becoming final

Award(s)

(in Russian roubles)

Enforcement status (prior to the quashing) Quashing Length of non-enforcement prior to the quashing (separate complaint) Just satisfaction granted
1. 24130/04

10/05/2004

Vyacheslav Matveyevich BARANOV

26/01/1949

Svobodnyy

Russian

Svobodnyy Town Court

29/03/2000

19/05/2000

Military Commissioner of Amur

The commissariat was ordered to send necessary documents to an insurance company remained unenforced Presidium of the Amur Regional Court

22/12/2003

EUR 5,000
2. 24916/04

04/06/2004

Nikolay Grigoryevich ZAYTSEV

04/03/1961

Strugi Krasnyye

Russian

Strugokrasnenskiy District Court

17/04/2003

28/04/2003

Military Commissioner of Leningrad Region

Ground of the dismissal from military service was changed fully enforced Presidium of Pskov Regional Court

19/12/2003

EUR 5,000
3. 38108/04

01/09/2004

Aleksandr Valentinovich BOCHKAREV

09/06/1953

Istra

Russian

1) Military Court of the 5th Garrison

15/03/2004

26/03/2004

Federal Security Service

provide the applicant and his family with housing 1) remained unenforced 1) Regional Military Court of North Caucasus 18/01/2005 1) 9 months 22 days EUR 5,000 + EUR 135
2) Military Court of the 5th Garrison

01/06/2006

25/10/2006

Federal Security Service

2) enforced on 30 August 2007 2) 10 months and 3 days
4. 43535/04

26/11/2004

Leonid Ilyich KUDRYAVTSEV

25/10/1937

Moscow

Russian

Tverskoy District Court of Moscow

17/05/2002

28/05/2002

Military Commissioner of Moscow

Order to recalculate and pay the pension enforced until 30/04/2004 (RUB 54,682.85 was paid) Presidium of Moscow City Court

01/07/2004

EUR 5,000 + EUR 132
5. 1711/05

05/12/2004

Grigoriy Pavlovich POLUSMYAK

22/06/1930

Moscow

Russian

Tverskoy District Court of Moscow

17/05/2002

28/05/2002

Military Commissioner of Moscow

Order to recalculate and pay the pension fully enforced Presidium of Moscow City Court

09/06/2004

6. 13825/06

26/02/2006

Sergey Nikolayevich SITNIKOV

26/05/1959

Voronezh

Russian

Tsentralnyy District Court of Voronezh

02/08/05

26/08/05

Military Commissioner of Voronezh Region

RUB 26,752.22 (social benefits arrears) + RUB 1,000 (monthly compensation) remained unenforced Presidium of Voronezh Regional Court

19/12/2005

EUR 5,000 + EUR 300
7. 14070/06

14/03/2006

Ivan Dmitriyevich RUSSKIKH

02/09/1940

Stavropol

Russian

Promyshlennyy District Court

of Stavropol

01/09/2004

13/09/2004

Military Commissioner of Stavropol Region

RUB 36,000 (unpaid compensation) + RUB 1,000 (monthly compensation) lump sum RUB 43,000 was paid on 03/11/2004 Presidium of Stavropol Regional Court

26/09/2005

8. 14101/06

17/03/2006

Vladimir Nikiforovich STEPANOV

29/09/1940

Stavropol

Russian

 

Aleksandr Aleksandrovich KUKSOV

15/07/1945

Stavropol

Russian

 

Aleksandr Viktorovich BYCHKOV

11/11/1947

Stavropol

Russian

 

Stefan Stefanovich ZHURAVSKIY

26/01/1942

Stavropol

Russian

 

Nikolay Grigoryevich KOPEYKA

17/05/1941

Stavropol

Russian

 

Anatoliy Petrovich KORYTIN

21/02/1947

Stavropol

Russian

 

Leonid Vasilyevich ZHIVOTIKOV

22/02/1942

Stavropol

Russian

 

Valeriy Sergeyevich NOVOSELOV

21/02/1947

Stavropol

Russian

 

Veniamin Grigoryevich NEFEDOV

27/08/1940

Stavropol

Russian

 

Viktor Ivanovich SHAPOVALOV

14/07/1946

Stavropol

Russian

 

Anatoliy Aleksandrovich PETROV

12/01/1942

Stavropol

Russian

Promyshlennyy District Court

of Stavropol

30/06/2004

12/07/2004

Military Commissioner of Stavropol Region

RUB 41,000 (unpaid compensation) + RUB 1,000 (monthly compensation) fully enforced on July 2004 Presidium of Stavropol Regional Court

26/09/2005

9. 17664/06

06/03/2006

Vladimir Yakovlevich KUZMIN

24/02/1930

Voronezh

Russian

Tsentralnyy District Court of Voronezh

02/08/05

26/08/05

Military Commissioner of Voronezh Region

RUB 34,983.47 (social benefits arrears) + RUB 2,150.46 (monthly compensation) remained unenforced Presidium of Voronezh Regional Court

19/12/2005

EUR 5,000 + EUR 300
10. 25722/06

12/05/2006

Sergey Vasilyevich MOCHALOV

13/03/1964

Yoshkar Ola

Russian

Yoshkar-Ola Town Court

24/02/2004

06/03/2004

The Ministry of Interior of the Mariy-El Republic

RUB 85,774.59 (lump sum for damages) + RUB 4,752.15 (court expenses) + RUB 3,254.96 (monthly disability payments) partially enforced (monthly payments were paid until 04/2005) Presidium of Supreme Court of Mariy-El Republic

02/12/2005

EUR 5,000
11. 25798/06

06/04/2006

Leonid Valeriyevich BELYASOV

29/10/1954

Voronezh

Russian

 

Ilya Vladimirovich SIVOLDAYEV

Tsentralnyy District Court of Voronezh

02/08/2005

26/08/2005

The Voronezh Regional Military Commissariat

RUB 22,048.1

(pension arrears) + RUB 2,150 (monthly food allowance)

remained unenforced The Presidium of Voronezh Regional Court

19/12/2005

3 months 23 days EUR 5,000 + EUR 300
12. 45413/06

03/09/2006

Sergey Ivanovich

UMANETS

19/04/1954

Belgorod

Russian

 

Aleksandr Aleksandrovich NAUMKIN

Oktyabrskiy District Court of Belgorod 30/11/05

07/02/06

Belgrad Law School of Ministry of Interior

RUB 439,410.56

(lump sum)

RUB 19,404.17 (monthly)

non-pec EUR 6,500

remained unenforced Presidium of the Belgorod Regional Court 29/06/06 4 months 22 days EUR 5,000 + EUR 300
13. 19942/07

28/03/2007

Valentin Mikhaylovich BARKOV

09/02/1947

Smolensk

Russian

Justice of Peace for Yelninskiy District

Circuit No. 35, Smolensk Region

26/09/2006

08/10/2006

Military Commissioner of the Smolensk Region

RUB 25,445.59

(pension arrears)

RUB 7,043.31 was paid Presidium of Smolensk Regional Court

21/02/2007

4 months 13 days EUR 5,000 + EUR 4
14. 39661/07

30/07/2007

Oleg Anatolyevich KOZLOVSKIY

07/08/1966

Bataysk

Russian

Oktyabrskiy District Court of Rostov

03/02/06

14/02/06

Rostoblvoyenkomat and the Ministry of Defence of Russian Federation

RUB 79,120.34 (lump sum) RUB 6,086.34 (monthly) until 01/02/2007, that is the applicant’s next medical examination fully enforced on 22/06/2006 Presidium of Rostov Regional Court

01/02/2007

15. 47465/07

25/08/2007

Pavel Nikolayevich KORCHAGIN

15/03/1961

Krasnodar

Russian

 

Khabibula Aleksandrovich ZAYNETDINOV

Krasnodar Garnison Military Court

23/12/05

10/01/06

Krasnodar High School of Aviation

Order to recalculate and pay salary arrears remained unenforced Presidium of Northern Caucasus Circuit Military Court

20/03/2007

EUR 5,000 + EUR 300

 

16. 8295/08

15/12/2007

Igor Anatolyevich MARTYNOV

03/11/1974

Mokshan

Russian

Mokshanskyy District Court of Penza Region

12/02/07

12/02/07

Division of Internal Affairs of Mokshanskiy District

RUB 35,793 (compensation for overtime) + RUB 4219 (judicial expences) partially enforced (RUB 862.55) on 17/08/2007 Presidium of the Penza Regional Court

22/06/2007

17. 52271/08

28/03/2008

Natalya Alekseyevna GAFAROVA

16/01/1956

Vladimiro-Aleksandrovskoye

Russian

 

Yekaterina Ivanovna MATVEYEVA

26/05/1962

Zolotaya Dolina

Russian

 

Alevtina Nikolayevna ZHEZHERUN

28/03/1963

Zolotaya Dolina

Russian

 

Nina Ivanovna BYKASOVA

31/05/1961

Zolotaya Dolina

Russian

 

Vladimir Vasilyevich FIRSTOV

02/08/1948

Zolotaya Dolina

Russian

 

Valentina Vladimirovna FIRSTOVA

Zolotaya Dolina

Russian

 

Sergey Valeryevich KETOV

16/02/1977

Zolotaya Dolina

Russian

Partizanskiy District Court of Primorskiy Region

13/06/07

13/06/07

Military Commander of village Zolotaya Dolina of Partizanskiy District

RUB 44,759.22

RUB 27,778.49

RUB 45,798.57

RUB 12,420.42

RUB 47,622.90

RUB 59,148.16

RUB 46,628.57

remained unenforced Presidium of Primorskiy Regional Court

02/11/2007

EUR 5,000 each
18. 55432/08

06/09/2008

Sergey Sergeyevich DUDOV

28/11/1946

St Petersburg

Russian

Justice of Peace for the 201st Circuit of St Petersburg

19/03/07

Federal Security Service of St Petersburg and Leningrad District

RUB 14,700.00 (compensation for damage and health recovery) remained unenforced Presidium of St Petersburg City Court

26/03/2008

EUR 5,000 + EUR 12

1   2

Добавить комментарий

Ваш e-mail не будет опубликован.

*

code